Premier Sotheby's International Realty N Collier Blvd, Marco Island

Angelica Andrews met with us for the first time on a Wednesday, and had us under contract with a full cash offer by Monday. She staged the home and brought in photographers who produced an incredible promotional video on day one. She kept us completely in the loop as the offers started to roll in. Angelica was very skilled in dealing with competing offers, advising us every step along the way. She led us through the entire process from over a thousand miles away, and we closed within about three weeks of our initial meeting! We feel that Angelica is a master at her craft, and would highly recommend her to anyone in the market for an exceptional realtor.

We had a wonderful experience working with Devin. She is incredibly knowledgeable in all aspects, and made the sale of our home much easier for us. She is professional, efficient, and kept our best interest in mind at all times. Highly recommend. 12/10!

My husband and I regret hiring Gwen Tolson of Sotheby's as our realtor. We had just undergone a complete high end renovation of our house. She convinced us into greatly underpricing our house, discrediting everything I pointed out about how high real estate was selling around us and how much larger and nicer our house was. She never provided any comparable sales (comps) instead, she just gave us a print out showing what our house sold for before we bought it (like we didn't know that). When we mentioned to Gwen we thought our home was underpriced, she wrote us a long ranting text implying how offended she was, wanting to know which realtor put that idea into our head, instead of discussing this with us. Instead of acknowledging the many expensive and unique features of our home and lot, she even put down our lot, although our house was on a large double waterfront lot with a long unobstructed view with a brand new dock lift, and direct ocean access. Our house was a large CBS 4/3 one story waterfront pool/spa home with high ceilings, walk-in closets and a 3 car garage. We had just invested several hundred thousand dollars renovating it, installing all new impact windows and doors, a new dock and lift, new cabinets throughout the house with quartz countertops in the kitchen, 3 baths and laundry room, new bosch appliances, new washer/dryer, new Italian porcelain tile and silhouette blinds throughout, 2 new 3-ton Carrier AC units and ductwork, new paint inside and out. We made no profit from it because of her not being a professional and researching recent neighborhood sales. Her listing write-up on our house did not even mention details of our high end renovation. Our house listing included a photo of someone's old unrenovated bathroom which she never removed after I pointed it out several times. I also wondered a few times if she was working for us or the buyers since they would be her new neighbors. We had two full priced offers within minutes of it going on the market, but she still negotiated with us doing additional work and convinced us to give away some of our expensive furniture with the deal. Soon after selling our house, a house across the street sold for 450k more than ours. Their house and lot is smaller, didn't have as good water view, two years older with only a one car garage. I decided to post this because it is still bothering us a year later.

I chose to work with Deanna and Vince Sydlosky when my family decided the time had come to sell my parent's building lot on Marco Island. They had maintained a long term relationship with my parents long before they had any interest in selling. They were always informative, but never pressuring. My parents like them so much that when the time came, the choice was obvious--it would be Deanna and Vince. From the first time I spoke with Vince and Deanna until the day of closing, I had the most delightful experience. Vince and Deanna are seasoned professionals who have decades of experience and a depth of knowledge unsurpassed by anyone in Florida Real Estate. Their knowledge of the area coupled with wonderful insights on pricing, marketing, vetting offers, etc. was invaluable and resulted in a seamless sale at an excellent price. I felt like they were always a step ahead of me and anticipated all of my questions and needs. Everything about working with them was stellar and they actually made what could have been a stressful experience a great deal of fun! I hope you have the opportunity to work with Deanna and Vince. They are consummate professionals, wonderful and honest people and they will make your buying or selling experience a joy. I can't recommend them highly enough.

I worked with Paul selling 5 properties for a family member. Historically, I’ve had many experiences buying and selling property with a realtors over the years but I have to say Paul is impressive. He is exceptionally professional, responsive, hard working and tackled every obstacle we threw at him as something to solve rather than a road block. He was incredibly creative in getting the deals done. He outstanding in his communication and feedback. I received constant updates throughout the process. Anyone looking to buy or sell a home will be very impressed with his work ethic, professionalism and his overall demeanor.

It was a pleasure dealing with Stanley Niemczyk at Premier Sotheby's International Realty. He is knowledgeable and dependable in keeping clients informed. I would have no hesitation in recommending him.

I worked with Melissa Baker both as a buyer for a home, and a seller for our condo. She went above and beyond my expectations! I had many questions as the home we bought was a “smart house”. She patiently helped me and even stopped by several times to help me in person. Whenever I sent her a message, she responded to me promptly-which to me is very important. Also, after we had gone back to our MA home I decided to switch the lamps in my new home with the lamps in the condo we had for sale. She was able to switch the lamps out for me before we even had the first open house. Then she had one of her workers switch a chair and a TV, at no charge to us. On top of all this, she was friendly and pleasant to deal with. You can tell that she really enjoys working with people!!

Paul Strong is one of the best Real Estate agents I have worked with. He has a very good understanding of the local market, and provides great advice. He has helped me with several transaction in Marco Island; and I have referred many other people to him that are equally pleased with his services.

If you are interested in renting great properties in Marco Island, this is the place! Our agent Annie Shaughnessy is very knowledgeable and extremely professional. The office staff was very helpful with the receipt of an item we needed to ship to their office. Very pleased with the entire experience.

If you are in the marketplace for a new home or selling your home, I recommend Sotheby's. They are extremely professional and will help with all of your needs. Thanks to everyone at Sotheby's I had a wonderful experience!!!