Goodville Mutual Casualty Company W Main St, New Holland

Five stars from us on the way Goodville Mutual processed our recent roof leak claim. From the initial call-in to receiving the reimbursement check, the process had no hassles. Thank you.

Our daughter hit a deer on her way home one evening. Fortunately, she was uninjured and the car sustained some damage, but was still driveable. Goodville Mutual was fast to assess the situation and provide hassle free compensation. Hats off to the Goodville team.

Very fast response to hail damage. Fair claim price. Quick payment. No problems, no questions. I had neighbors who weren't so lucky. Very happy.

Goodville handled an auto comp claim. I was very satisfied with the claim being settled. Always received prompt attention when I had phone contact, too.

Where in the hell do I start? I can't access my account online because setting up an account is impossible considering it isn't recognizing my account #. After buying a new vehicle and adding insurance to an existing account, I requested proof of insurance via email on a weekend and my request was denied and I was told to contact my agent for proof of insurance. Maybe I would had it not been a weekend douchbags. This is the poorest service I have ever dealt with when it comes to my personal accounts. The one star is only there because I couldn't leave a comment without giving at least one star. This company gets ZERO stars and will soon get one less customer!

Hail damage claim processed and received a check in 6 Days. This is a great company! Very impressed with promptness and processing. Thanks Goodville Mutual!

Because we paid a friend to tow our car, we didn't have receipts for the full cost. Goodville refunded the full amount according to our policy anyway. Thank you!!

Absolutely everything that is wrong with the insurance industry. I have owned my home for 23 years and never made a single claim. I have no debt and excellent credit. I made a book keeping error, and forgot to pay my premium. They refused to even consider issuing a new policy. Hateful people.

I highly recommend this company to anyone seeking an excellent provider of insurance! I have the confidence that they got me covered. These are not empty words. I've had two total losses , both of which were beyond my control, and they came through without hassle or complaint. Business like this is uncommon today! Thank You GMCC Conrad Gehman

Excellent response to claim filed for damaged roof. Initial check received within a few days, with balance shortly after repairs were completed. Highly satisfied with the way our claim was handled.